How robust is your business transformation strategy? According to our room of executive experts, success isn’t as simple as implementing the hottest new software and tracking the number of users, licences, or prompts. Experience has taught them that, without critical considerations in place, a transformation project can easily become an expensive misstep.
On Thursday 15th of October, Charlie Grubb (Senior Managing Director, Robert Half) hosted the latest event in our Leadership in the Boardroom series. The event covered challenges around delivering successful business transformation, with Matt Duncan (UK Managing Director, Protiviti) as the keynote speaker.
The lively discussion, held with executives from various sectors, drew on insights from Protiviti's 2026 GlobalTransformation Survey, conducted in conjunction with the University of Oxford. Together, they covered the role of boards in leading successful AI implementation and digital transformation initiatives, how to balance innovation with risk, and practical considerations for digital transformation planning.
1. Alignment versus agreement: define the details
Agreement and alignment leave a lot to interpretation when it comes to business transformation. Business leaders may support a broad strategy but interpret its goals and execution differently. “There's often alignment. There's far less agreement on what that means and the route to the outcome,” says keynote speaker Matt Duncan.
“Alignment at the top level is not the same as having agreement on what it means for the organisation.” He recommends defining the outcome, success metrics, the work that will stop in favour of the transformation initiative, and establishing which parties are accountable.
2. Keep it clear with simple, measurable priorities
Too many disconnected digital transformation KPIs can obscure what matters most. By delegating a small number of simple, measurable priorities, you can effectively connect BAU work and customer value to the organisation’s overall goals.
“From experience, what comes through relatively quickly if you put aside a strategy is that no one truly understands what the ‘absolute currency’ of that business is. There's a whole multitude of KPIs measuring a multitude of things, but there aren't two or three or four or five absolutes, which I would always call a ‘currency,’” said one attendee.
“If you do get the currency right, that becomes the purpose because it's all-encompassing. It's the lifeblood of the business. With some checks and balances along the way, it should create capacity across the rest of the team — that capacity is there to create bandwidth to enable those bigger, functional, global changes.”
3. Active leadership over passive sponsorship
The most successful changes aren’t treated as IT projects, but business-wide transformation initiatives led by senior leaders with an explicit role in guiding the change. Anything less can cause teams to pull in different directions.
“There's a specific role that you must play, and it waxes and wanes in importance and profile of what you must do throughout, and it's different to the day job, and it’s so often overlooked. It might be just left to IT. No one dares to talk to that business leader and say, ‘We need you to show up like this,’” said an attendee. “It should not be a passive thing. There's an active leadership role to play if you're in a transformation scenario, and often it's left as passive.”
Another attendee agreed, saying: “If it's large enough to be a transformation in the business, I must be bothered about it. If it's not large enough to be a transformation in the business; it's probably not a transformation. It's probably an evolution of somebody's department that they can do on the side.”
Read: Shaping the Future of Tech
4. Measure by value, not activity
AI adoption or usage numbers are not successful transformation outcomes. The most impactful change initiatives start by identifying a business problem, testing a focused use case, and tracking its impact (including costs and potential growth) rather than focusing only on efficiencies gained. One attendee said:
“There's often a confusion between ideation and it becoming a transformation — the ideation stage is key for thinking through what the value is — what’s the value to the business? That does two things: it filters out ideas that might add 1 or 2% on paper and don't really merit being a transformation. And the second one, which is if it gets through that filter, you now have clarity throughout the organisation over what needs to be done to implement it, what value it will bring to the business. It's so much easier then to keep everybody aligned.”
5. People and future capabilities are central to change
People can be effectively supported in navigating transformation through clear top-down communication and recognition of the hard work completed throughout the project. Another attendee added, “Having behavioural metrics, as well. I think we can focus too much on just the performance and not always the behaviour and how you do things, and having that very clearly agreed from the top and filtering that down.”
Another attendee recalled a time when poor executive communication on a transformation project caused lasting issues for the business. “We acquired a business, and the alignment was clear at the board level. Integrate the tech. Don't do anything with the team because, while they're still on their own systems, we need everyone,” he said. “Because the leadership, me included, weren't talking enough about the message we were sending, the CFO would go up and drop a slightly different hint, which would send a remote team spiralling. Six months later, the system still hadn't been done, and the culture was on the floor because people didn't know whether they were coming or going. It was about clarity of comms and board-level alignment.”
Moreover, training—especially AI training—should include all generations to prepare the business for its future, not just what it is today. As Matt Duncan put it: “One thing I often think is a bit of a miss in succession planning is that it focuses on the organisation we have today, forgetting the organisation we want to be in 2029.”
Read: Senior finance succession planning: building a future-proof strategy
6. Balance financial measures with people-focused outcomes
The leadership challenge, across both PE-backed and founder-led businesses, is to set clear financial goals without letting them become the only measure of success. Customer outcomes, workforce capability, and long-term direction should also matter. One attendee said:
“With a non-PE business, it’s much more holistic. You're looking at business growth, but you're looking a lot more at the people. You're looking a lot more at the talent. You're looking a lot more at the longer-term strategic plans and where the business might be in 10 years. With PE, you are looking at that because even if you're exiting a PE, there needs to be some meat on the bone for the next person.”
By communicating those priorities clearly and consistently from the leadership level, you create an environment where people understand the value the change is intended to create and how success is judged. Matt Duncan says, “Cash is king. And then the next thing is how do your customers feel, and then what are the employees feeling? Those are the three fundamental things.”
For more insights on C-suite alignment and performance metrics, read Protiviti’s 2026 Global Transformation Survey. To prepare your teams for the challenge ahead, reach out to our expert recruiters and support your initiative with the best talent.